'El Capitan'
My Profile
My Disclaimer


Recent Entries

Santa Cruz, California
God Bless The United States Air Force
Must.Resist.Dreaded.Cuteness.Powers!
Another Victim of Katrina
Happy 31st Birthday to Dave at Garfield Ridge
University Professor and Gun Expert
When You've Gotta Go...
I.Just.Couldn't.Resist.
Those Wacky BBC Headline Writers
Freak'n Blogspot! Kiss My Arse-Holio!!!!


Daily Intel

Drudge Report
Opinion Journal
Neal's Nuze
Jamestown Foundation
The Network
Cybercast News
Claremont Institute
Missile Defence
Sonshi
The Onion

Daily Reading

Michelle Malkin
Ace of Spades HQ
Black Five
Mudville Gazette
Cox & Forkum
MauserGirl
Thoughts In Dixie
Lindsay Fincher
Sgt & Mrs Hub
Most Certainly Not
Did You See This
Jake Silver Show
Army Wife
Doc in the Box
Duty in the Desert
Military Motivator

Military Blogs

MILBLOGS
Prev | List | Random | Next
Join
Powered by RingSurf!



B-Sides

Chrenkoff Down Under
Desultory Butterfly
MauserGirl
Toni's View
Right Wing Conspiracy
Li'l Miss Attila
Hollywood Refugee
Esprit d'Escalier
Lindsay Fincher
Gateway Pundit
Superman's Cape
Quirky Chick
Immigration Blog
Trans-Int
The Decadent West
Late Great Diplomad
Caption This
Veri-Frank
Vodka Pundit
Eject Eject Eject
Terrorism Unveiled
Iowa Hawk
Protest Warrior
Rusty Gurl
Sinclair Wong
Our Man in Hanoi
Natural Disaster Blog
Angry in Canada
Prof. Mike Adams
The Torch
Alarming News
Yankee Conservative
Granite State Pundit
Toronto Crawler
Emotional Toothpaste
Orson Scott Card
Card's Weekly Column
NA-NO-BLOG-MO

Stuff I Want

Buy My Cigars.Com
Cigar Blog
Cigars International
Sierra Nevada Pale Ale
Virgin Galactic
My Secret Lair
Dillon Aero, Inc.
Dream Car
Amazon Wish List
Payment Calculator

Best Damn Teams

San Francisco Giants
San Francisco 49ers
Essendon Bombers

Alma Maters

Soquel High School
U of Cal. Riverside
Cal. State University
Air Force ROTC

Mid East Blogs

Star From Mosul
Neurotic Iraqi Wife
Fayrouz Breakroom
Free Iraq
Iraq The Model
Blog Iran
Lebanon News Blog

Afghan Blogs

Afghan Warrior

Older Archives


Undeserved Recognition
The 2006 Milblog Awards The 2005 Milblog Awards The 2005 Weblog Awards 2006 Time Person of the Year

Bean Counters



Powered by Blogger
Blogarama - The Blog Directory

Thursday, September 29, 2005
The V-22 Osprey: A Blessing or a Curse?

WASHINGTON — The Pentagon on Wednesday gave the go-ahead to begin full-rate production of the V-22 Osprey, the hybrid helicopter-airplane that the Marine Corps considers vital to the future of its air fleet. (Fox)

The concept of the V-22 Osprey is amazing. The technology is state of the art. The mission it will accomplish is vital. So why the concern? This new weapons system is so complex it's almost too fragile to be used in the harsh and unforgiving world of military operations. Certainly it's been tested and retested, but none of those tests involved small arms damage to the critical fiber optic cables that run throughout the aircraft. The tests didn't involve extreme last-minute evasive maneuvers pilots make when an RPG or shoulder-launched missile is launched at them from a rooftop in Baghdad. Generally speaking, this aircraft has yet to prove that it has what it takes to survive in today's operational environment.

The Marine Corps is ordering a few hundred of these aircraft, and is quickly reshaping their insertion and extraction doctrines around the capabilities they're hoping it has. The Air Force is ordering 50, and the Navy is getting just under 40 of them. We of course have confidence that the DoD leaders and Generals who have approved the Osprey know what they're doing, but we would be lying if we said we weren't uneasy about it. After all, who's going to be most affected by it; the GS-15s who signed the contracts or the Airmen and Marines who must fly it into combat and depend on it for survival on a daily basis.

The big picture discussion regarding the Osprey and other 'High-Tech' weapons is the balance between numbers and capabilities. Is it better to spend 50 billion dollars to buy a limited number of 'fragile' aircraft, or should we spend the same amount to purchase and upgrade many more of the combat proven systems we currently use? In other words, buy 400 Osprey vs. 1000 Chinooks or Blackhawks. Once again, that's where confidence in the leadership kicks in. One would hope that the leadership is knowledgeable that the one of a kind capabilities of the Osprey out-perform the existing capabilities of our current systems, making them obsolete.

Is this post simply an opinion? Yes. Am I concerned? You bet your ass I am. When nearly 2 dozen fellow service members have died in Osprey crashes so far, it's easy to see why many people are concerned. We need to have confidence in our weapons. We need to make sure minor 'software glitches' such as this never happens during combat.

A lot of us will feel more confident about the Osprey once it has proven itself worthy. Until then, expect to see a lot of the Osprey pilots and passengers crossing fingers and praying more than usual as they board the aircraft.

posted by El Capitan at 11:37 AM


6 Comments:
Anonymous Anonymous said...

For some reason I've been under the impression that the Osprey had been in continuous use for years? Hmmm...

2:31 PM  
Blogger El Capitan said...

Continuous testing... but not full-up use. Actually the testing was stopped quite a bit due to accidents and things breaking, but supposedly it's ready for production now.

4:20 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

A weapons system via Congressman from contracting districts. Or, a weapons system via Congress. Sorta like the Beretta 9mm. Scary. Will the troops want the Blackhawk back like many want the .45 Auto back?

12:24 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Please check for other articles on the

Osprey. The Dallas Morning News had 1

about the revised testing.

One advantage that the Osprey has over

all Helicopters is the lack of the

thump-thump noise.

All troops on the ground would hear

would be prop/engine noise.

The has also been a request for a new

version with 2 wings with tilt rotors

open to all contractors not just

existing Osprey contractors.

During the NEW tests, the vortex ring

effect that killed all the Marines

earlier was extensively analyzed &

OVERCOME!

Thanks for your great weblog.

Please keep writing.

Sine Nomine

1:25 PM  
Blogger Allison said...

That's scary to know that several serviceman died in the testing of the Osprey. It sounds like it has the potential to be a great resource, however until it's necessarily refined I wouldn't volunteer for that job.

11:27 PM  
Blogger Professor Howdy said...

Nice blog - Great Article...

8:32 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home